Deutsche Telekom AG v The Republic of India
新加坡国际商事法庭 · [2023] SGHC(I) 7摘要
快速理解这份材料
编辑摘要
新加坡国际商事法庭审理德国电信诉印度共和国关于ICC仲裁裁决的撤销申请案件。
AI 研究摘要
新加坡国际商事法庭审理了德国电信诉印度共和国关于撤销ICC仲裁裁决的申请案件。该案主要涉及仲裁裁决的承认与执行、管辖权异议以及撤销仲裁裁决等核心争点。
- 案件由新加坡国际商事法庭审理,当事人为德国电信与印度共和国。
- 争议焦点包括仲裁裁决的承认与执行、管辖权异议及撤销仲裁裁决。
文书原文
IN THE SINGAPORE INTERNATIONAL COMMERCIAL COURT
OF THE REPUBLIC OF SINGAPORE
[2023] SGHC(I) 7
Originating Summons No 8 of 2022 (HC/Summonses Nos 155 and 720 of
2022 and SIC/Summonses Nos 24 and 45 of 2022)
Between
Deutsche Telekom AG
… Plaintiff
And
The Republic of India
… Defendant
JUDGMENT
[Arbitration — Award — Recourse against award]
[Arbitration — Conduct of arbitration — Waiver of objections]
[Arbitration — Enforcement — Foreign award]
[Arbitration — Stay of court proceedings — Grounds]
[Res judicata — Applicable principles]
[Res judicata — Extended doctrine of res judicata]
[Res judicata — Issue estoppel]
Version No 1: 11 May 2023 (15:27 hrs)
TABLE OF CONTENTS
INTRODUCTION............................................................................................1
BACKGROUND ..............................................................................................3
THE ARBITRATION GENERALLY .......................................................................3
THE DEVAS-ANTRIX AGREEMENT ..................................................................8
DT’S INVESTMENT IN INDIA ..........................................................................10
INDIA’S TERMINATION OF THE DEVAS-ANTRIX AGREEMENT ........................11
THE ICC ARBITRATION .................................................................................13
INDIAN INVESTIGATION OF THE DEVAS-ANTRIX AGREEMENT ......................14
DISCUSSION .................................................................................................17
SUM 155 – APPLICATION TO SET ASIDE LEAVE ORDER..................................17
Jurisdictional objections ..........................................................................17
(1) The illegality argument ...............................................................18
(A) India’s case on illegality ...................................................19
(B) DT’s case on illegality ......................................................33
(C) Analysis of India’s case on illegality ................................34
(2) The pre-investment expenditure argument..................................53
(A) India’s case on pre-investment expenditure......................53
(B) DT’s case on pre-investment expenditure.........................54
(C) Analysis of India’s case on pre-investment
expenditure........................................................................54
(3) The indirect investment argument...............................................55
(A) India’s case on indirect investment...................................55
(B) DT’s case on indirect investment ......................................56
(C) Analysis of India’s case on indirect investment ................56
ii
Version No 1: 11 May 2023 (15:27 hrs)
(4) The essential security interests argument....................................57
(A) India’s case on essential security interests .......................57
(B) DT’s case on essential security interests ..........................58
(C) Analysis of India’s case on essential security
interests .............................................................................58
Other grounds relied on by India.............................................................62
Estoppel, res judicata and waiver ............................................................64
(1) The NCLT, NCLAT and Supreme Court of India
judgments ....................................................................................64
(2) The Swiss Federal Supreme Court judgment..............................76
(3) The Interim and Final Awards ....................................................88
Conclusion on SUM 155 ..........................................................................98
SUM 24 – APPLICATION TO STAY HEARING OF SUMMONSES .........................99
SUM 45 – APPLICATION TO SUBMIT FURTHER EVIDENCE ............................103
SUM 720 – APPLICATION TO STRIKE OUT AFFIDAVIT EVIDENCE..................104
CONCLUSION.............................................................................................105
iii
Version No 1: 11 May 2023 (15:27 hrs)
This judgment is subject to final editorial corrections approved by the
court and/or redaction.
Deutsche Telekom AG
v
The Republic of India
[2023] SGHC(I) 7
Singapore International Commercial Court — Originating Summons No 8 of
2022 (HC/Summonses Nos 155 and 720 of 2022 and SIC/Summonses Nos 24
and 45 of 2022)
S Mohan J, Roger Giles IJ, Anselmo Reyes IJ
30 June, 1 July, 12 August 2022
30 January 2023 Judgment reserved.
Anselmo Reyes IJ (delivering the judgment of the court):
Introduction
1 The plaintiff investor (“DT”) is a multinational corporation incorporated
under the laws of the Federal Republic of Germany. Through its wholly-owned
subsidiary, Deutsche Telekom Asia Pte Ltd (“DT Asia”), it was a shareholder
in an Indian company, Devas Multimedia Private Limited (“Devas”).
2 The defendant State (“India”) is the Republic of India and was the
respondent in the relevant arbitration proceedings that took place as detailed
be
……
基本案情
德国电信就其与印度之间的Devvas-Antrix协议争议提起I……
案件文书
下载原始文书需登录会员账号。
