Kingdom of Spain v NextEra Energy Global Holdings BV and another
新加坡上诉法院 · [2026] SGCA 43摘要
快速理解这份材料
编辑摘要
西班牙以国家豁免为由申请撤销ICSID裁决在新加坡的登记令,上诉法院审理该争议。
文书原文
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE REPUBLIC OF SINGAPORE
[2026] SGCA 43
Court of Appeal / Civil Appeal No 11 of 2026
Between
Kingdom of Spain
… Appellant
And
(1) NextEra Energy Global
Holdings B.V.
(2) NextEra Energy Spain
Holdings B.V.
… Respondents
In the matter of Originating Application No 1283 of 2023 (Summons No 1371
of 2025)
Between
(1) NextEra Energy Global
Holdings B.V.
(2) NextEra Energy Spain
Holdings B.V.
… Applicants
And
Kingdom of Spain
… Respondent
Version No 1: 19 Oct 2026 (12:09 hrs)
JUDGMENT
[International Law — Sovereign immunity — Exceptions — Submission]
[International Law — Sovereign immunity — Exceptions — Arbitration]
[International Law — Conventions — Convention on the Settlement of
Investment Disputes between States and Nationals of other States]
[Arbitration — Award — Recourse against award — Setting aside]
Version No 1: 19 Oct 2026 (12:09 hrs)
This judgment is subject to final editorial corrections approved by the
court and/or redaction pursuant to the publisher’s duty in compliance
with the law, for publication in LawNet and/or the Singapore Law
Reports.
Kingdom of Spain
v
NextEra Energy Global Holdings BV and another
[2026] SGCA 43
Court of Appeal — Civil Appeal No 11 of 2026
Sundaresh Menon CJ, Ang Cheng Hock JCA and Hri Kumar Nair JCA
14 August 2026
19 October 2026 Judgment reserved.
Sundaresh Menon CJ (delivering the judgment of the court):
Introduction
1 The present appeal in CA/CA 11/2026 (“CA 11”) concerns the
registration and enforcement of an arbitral award (“Award”) rendered by the
International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes (“ICSID”). The
Award was made in favour of the respondents, whom we refer to as the “Dutch
Investors”, and against the appellant, the Kingdom of Spain (“Spain”).
2 The Dutch Investors subsequently obtained an order registering the
Award in Singapore (“Registration Order”). Spain applied to set aside the
Registration Order, principally on the ground that it was entitled to state
immunity under s 3 of the State Immunity Act 1979 (2020 Rev Ed) (“SIA”).
This application was dismissed by a Judge of the General Division of the High
Court (“Judge”): see NextEra Energy Global Holdings BV v Kingdom of Spain
Version No 1: 19 Oct 2026 (12:09 hrs)
Kingdom of Spain v NextEra Energy Global Holdings BV [2026] SGCA 43
[2026] SGHC 43 (“Judgment”). The Judge found that Spain could not rely on
state immunity under s 3 of the SIA to set aside the Registration Order because
the exceptions to state immunity in ss 4 and 11 of the SIA applied. The Judge
also declined to set aside the Registration Order under O 3 r 2(8) of the Rules
of Court 2021 (“ROC 2021”) in the interests of justice. Before us, Spain
contends that the Judge erred in each of these respects, and we address each
ground of appeal in turn.
3 Having reserved judgment after hearing parties’ submissions, we now
provide our decision along with our reasons.
Facts
Background to the dispute
4 The underlying dispute in the arbitration (“Dispute”) arose out of
investments made by the Dutch Investors in Spain. In May 2014, the Dutch
Investors commenced ICSID arbitration (ICSID Case No. ARB/14/11) against
Spain pursuant to the Energy Charter Treaty (17 December 1994), 2080 UNTS
95 (entered into force 16 April 1998) (“ECT”), to which Spain and the
Netherlands were both contracting parties.
5 The ICSID arbitration resulted in the Award rendered against Spain on
31 May 2019 by the arbitral tribunal (“Tribunal”). In accordance with the ICSID
framework, Spain then applied to annul the Award before an ad hoc annulment
committee (“annulment committee”) but was unsuccessful. The annulment
committee’s decision (“Decision on Annulment”) was delivered on 18 March
2022.
2
Version No 1: 19 Oct 2026 (12:09 hrs)
Kingdom of Spain v NextEra Energy Global Holdings BV [2026] SGCA 43
6 Before the Tribunal, Spain objected to its jurisdiction, arguing, amongst
other things, that the dispute resolution mechanism set out in Art 26 of the ECT
did not apply to controversies arising between an investor of a member state of
the European Union (“EU Member State”) and another EU Member State
(“intra-EU disputes”). Spain reiterated this argument before the annulment
committee. Both the Tribunal and the annulment committee rejected that
argument.
The proceedings before the Singapore court
7 In December 2023, the Dutch Investors applied in HC/OA 1283/2023
(“OA 1283”) to register the Award and the Decision on Annulment in the
General Division of the High Court. The Registration Order was granted in
January 2024, with the court ordering that the Award and the Decision on
Annulment be registered as if they were judgments of the General Division of
the High Court (Judgment at [8]).
8 In May 2025, Spain applied by way of HC/SUM 1371/2025 (“SUM
1371”) to set aside the Registration Order (Judgment at [9]).
9 The key issue before the court below was whether the exceptions to state
immunity in ss 4 and 11 of the SIA applied. Sections 3, 4 and 11 of the SIA state
as follows:
Immunity from jurisdiction
General immunity from jurisdiction
3.—(1) A State i
……
基本案情
荷兰投资者获ICSID对西班牙的胜诉裁决并在新加坡登记。西……
裁判要旨
裁判要旨
法官认定西班牙加入《ICSID公约》即构成对新加坡法院管辖权的同意(提交例外),且根据《能源宪章条……
案件文书
下载原始文书需登录会员账号。
