CEF and CEG v CEH
新加坡高等法院 · [2021] SGHC 114摘要
快速理解这份材料
编辑摘要
新加坡高等法院审理关于撤销国际商会仲裁裁决的申请,涉及仲裁协议范围及管辖权异议。
文书原文
IN THE GENERAL DIVISION OF
THE HIGH COURT OF THE REPUBLIC OF SINGAPORE
[2021] SGHC 114
Originating Summons No 241 of 2020
Between
(1) CEF
(2) CEG
… Plaintiffs
And
CEH
… Defendant
GROUNDS OF DECISION
[Arbitration] — [Award] — [Recourse against award] — [Setting aside]
[Arbitration] — [Agreement] — [Scope]
[Arbitration] — [Arbitral tribunal] — [Jurisdiction]
Version No 1: 19 May 2021 (11:19 hrs)
TABLE OF CONTENTS
BACKGROUND ..............................................................................................2
THE PARTIES ...................................................................................................2
THE CONTRACT...............................................................................................3
THE SERVICE AGREEMENT..............................................................................4
THE PARTIES’ DISPUTES...................................................................................5
THE ARBITRATION ...........................................................................................6
THE TERMS OF REFERENCE .............................................................................6
THE AWARD ....................................................................................................9
THIS APPLICATION.........................................................................................13
THE TRANSFER ORDER ...........................................................................14
THE PLAINTIFFS’ CASE ..................................................................................14
FIRST GROUND: BREACH OF ARBITRATION AGREEMENT OR MODEL
LAW ..............................................................................................................15
Two preliminary points ............................................................................16
(1) Scope of Art 34(2)(a)(iv) of the Model Law...............................16
(2) Waiver .........................................................................................17
(3) Conclusion on preliminary points ...............................................18
Enforceability ...........................................................................................19
(1) The Contract................................................................................19
(2) The ICC Rules.............................................................................21
(3) The Model Law...........................................................................22
(4) Conclusion ..................................................................................23
Workability ...............................................................................................23
(1) The award is not unworkable ......................................................24
i
Version No 1: 19 May 2021 (11:19 hrs)
(2) Effect of disassembling the Plant................................................26
(A) The plaintiffs’ position before the award..........................27
(B) The plaintiffs’ position after the award.............................27
Conclusion on Art 34(2)(a)(iv).................................................................31
SECOND GROUND: BEYOND THE SCOPE OF THE SUBMISSION TO
ARBITRATION ................................................................................................31
The plaintiffs’ case ...................................................................................31
Article 23 of the ICC Rules ......................................................................32
Paragraph 78 of the Terms of Reference .................................................34
Waiver ......................................................................................................36
THIRD GROUND: BREACH OF NATURAL JUSTICE.............................................37
The law .....................................................................................................37
The plaintiffs’ case ...................................................................................39
Counter-restitution was always a live issue.............................................39
(1) The Terms of Reference..............................................................41
(2) The defence and counterclaim ....................................................42
(3) The defendant’s prayer for relief.................................................44
(4) Opening submissions in the arbitration.......................................46
(5) Oral closing submissions ............................................................46
(6) The List of Issues ........................................................................49
(7) Post-hearing submissions ............................................................50
The award.................................................................................................51
Conclusion on s 24(b) and Art 34(2)(a)(ii) ..............................................53
CONCLUSION ON THE TRANSFER ORDER ......................
……
基本案情
原告与被告存在合同及服务协议纠纷,经ICC仲裁作……
案件文书
下载原始文书需登录会员账号。
