Frontier Holdings Ltd v Petroleum Exploration (Pvt) Ltd
新加坡国际商事法庭 · [2024] SGHC(I) 34摘要
快速理解这份材料
编辑摘要
Frontier Holdings Ltd申请撤销国际商会仲裁庭作出的无管辖权裁决。
文书原文
IN THE SINGAPORE INTERNATIONAL COMMERCIAL COURT
OF THE REPUBLIC OF SINGAPORE
[2024] SGHC(I) 34
Originating Application No 17 of 2024
Between
Frontier Holdings Limited
… Applicant
And
Petroleum Exploration
(Private) Limited
… Respondent
JUDGMENT
[Arbitration — Arbitral tribunal — Jurisdiction]
Version No 1: 30 Dec 2024 (15:12 hrs)
TABLE OF CONTENTS
INTRODUCTION............................................................................................1
FACTS...............................................................................................................2
THE PARTIES ...................................................................................................2
BACKGROUND TO THE DISPUTE .......................................................................2
THE RELEVANT CONTRACTUAL PROVISIONS....................................................5
THE JURISDICTIONAL RULING .......................................................................10
The majority reasoning ............................................................................13
The dissenting member’s opinion.............................................................20
Hashwani..................................................................................................23
THE PARTIES’ CASES................................................................................28
FHL ..............................................................................................................28
PEL...............................................................................................................40
MY DECISION ..............................................................................................44
CONCLUSION...............................................................................................49
i
Version No 1: 30 Dec 2024 (15:12 hrs)
This judgment is subject to final editorial corrections approved by the
court and/or redaction pursuant to the publisher’s duty in compliance
with the law, for publication in LawNet and/or the Singapore Law
Reports.
Frontier Holdings Ltd
v
Petroleum Exploration (Pvt) Ltd
[2024] SGHC(I) 34
Singapore International Commercial Court — Originating Application No 17
of 2024
Thomas Bathurst IJ
17 September 2024
30 December 2024 Judgment reserved.
Thomas Bathurst IJ:
Introduction
1 By SIC/OA 17/2024 (“OA 17”), Frontier Holdings Limited (“FHL”)
seeks an order setting aside a ruling on jurisdiction in International Chamber of
Commerce (“ICC”) Case 27567/AB/CPB between FHL as claimant and
Petroleum Exploration (Private) Limited, Pakistan (“PEL”) as respondent (the
“Jurisdictional Ruling”). In the Jurisdictional Ruling, the majority of the
tribunal concluded that it had no jurisdiction to resolve the dispute before it. In
these proceedings, FHL also seeks ancillary orders dealing with the further
conduct of the arbitration in the event that its application to set aside the
Jurisdictional Ruling is successful.
Version No 1: 30 Dec 2024 (15:12 hrs)
Frontier Holdings Ltd v Petroleum Exploration (Pvt) Ltd [2024] SGHC(I) 34
Facts
The parties
2 FHL is a company incorporated under the laws of Bermuda. FHL has a
branch office in the Republic of Pakistan (“Pakistan”). FHL is involved in the
exploration and production of oil and gas in Pakistan.1
3 PEL is a company incorporated under the laws of Pakistan. PEL, like
FHL, is in the business of exploration and production of oil and gas in Pakistan.
PEL’s concession portfolio includes fourteen concessions, eight development
and production leases, and one mining lease.2
Background to the dispute
4 On 5 January 2006, the President of Pakistan (the “President”) granted
PEL exploration licences in respect of two areas, Block No 2468-5 (the “Badin
South Block”) and Block No 2468-6 (the “Badin North Block”) (collectively,
the “Blocks”).3
5 On the same day, the President and PEL concluded Petroleum
Concession Agreements (“PCAs”) in respect of each block. By the PCAs, PEL
was awarded a 100% working interest in each block and thereby became a
Working Interest Owner (“WIO”) in respect of each block.4
1 First Affidavit of Evidence-in-Chief of Muhammad Nadeem Farooq dated 19 April
2024 (“1MNF”) at para 1.
2 Affidavit of Evidence-in-Chief of Bilal Kausar dated 15 July 2024 (“BK”) at para 4.
3 1MNF at para 13; BK at para 39.
4 1MNF at para 14; BK at para 40.
2
Version No 1: 30 Dec 2024 (15:12 hrs)
Frontier Holdings Ltd v Petroleum Exploration (Pvt) Ltd [2024] SGHC(I) 34
6 The relevant provisions in the PCA for each block are identical and I
refer to them below. By way of background, however, three matters should be
noted. First, Art VII of the PCAs contains provisions setting out the terms on
which PEL could assign or transfer the whole or any part of its interests to a
third party. It provides that the terms of such transfer or assignment requires
government approval and the assignee or transferee is required to assume all
obligations under the PCA or any licence.5
7 Second, there was annexed to the PCAs a form of Joint Operating
Agreement (“JOA”).
……
基本案情
Frontier Holdings Limited作为申请人,请求撤销其在国际商会案件27567/AB/CPB中针对P……
案件文书
下载原始文书需登录会员账号。
