Hulley Enterprises Ltd and others v The Russian Federation
新加坡国际商事法院 · [2025] SGHC(I) 19摘要
快速理解这份材料
编辑摘要
新加坡国际商事法院审理关于俄罗斯联邦主张国家豁免时是否适用跨国争点禁反言原则的案件。
文书原文
IN THE SINGAPORE INTERNATIONAL COMMERCIAL COURT
OF THE REPUBLIC OF SINGAPORE
[2025] SGHC(I) 19
Originating Application No 5 of 2025 (High Court (General Division)
Summons No 286 of 2025)
Between
(1) Hulley Enterprises Ltd
(2) Yukos Universal Ltd
(3) Veteran Petroleum Ltd
… Claimants
And
The Russian Federation
… Defendant
JUDGMENT
[Arbitration — Conduct of arbitration — Estoppel]
[Arbitration — Enforcement — Foreign award]
[International Law — Sovereign immunity — Sections 3(1) and 11(1) State
Immunity Act 1979 (2020 Rev Ed)]
[Res Judicata — Issue estoppel]
Version No 1: 25 Jul 2025 (17:12 hrs)
TABLE OF CONTENTS
INTRODUCTION............................................................................................1
THE RUSSIAN FEDERATION’S APPLICATION.....................................4
OUR DECISION ON THE PRELIMINARY ISSUES.................................7
BACKGROUND ..............................................................................................7
THE STATE IMMUNITY ACT 1979....................................................................7
THE ENERGY CHARTER TREATY ...................................................................16
THE RUSSIAN FEDERATION’S PROCEEDINGS BEFORE THE DUTCH SEAT
COURTS .........................................................................................................19
Article 45 Argument .................................................................................19
Investor/Investment Argument..................................................................21
Article 21 Purported Jurisdiction Argument............................................21
Article 21 Mandate Argument ..................................................................22
THE FINAL DISMISSAL OF THE RUSSIAN FEDERATION’S FOUR
ARGUMENTS AS TO JURISDICTION ..................................................................23
PROCEEDINGS BEFORE THE ENGLISH COURTS ...............................................25
THE RUSSIAN FEDERATION’S ARGUMENT.....................................................27
THE CLAIMANTS’ ARGUMENT.......................................................................30
THE DECISION IN DEUTSCHE TELEKOM (CA) ................................................31
The decision at first instance of the SICC ................................................31
The decision on appeal.............................................................................32
DISPOSITION................................................................................................40
IS THE DECISION IN DEUTSCHE TELEKOM (CA) BINDING AUTHORITY
FOR THE PROPOSITION THAT THE DOCTRINE OF TRANSNATIONAL ISSUE
i
Version No 1: 25 Jul 2025 (17:12 hrs)
ESTOPPEL CAN BE APPLIED TO A QUESTION OF STATE IMMUNITY
ARISING UNDER THE STATE IMMUNITY ACT? ................................................40
ARE THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE APPLICATION OF THE DOCTRINE OF
TRANSNATIONAL ISSUE ESTOPPEL SATISFIED?...............................................47
WHETHER TRANSNATIONAL ISSUE ESTOPPEL CONTRADICTS A DE
NOVO REVIEW OF QUESTIONS OF STATE IMMUNITY?......................................50
TRANSNATIONAL ISSUE ESTOPPEL CANNOT BE USED TO ENLARGE THE
STATUTORY JURISDICTION OF SINGAPORE COURTS........................................54
ARE THERE ANY POLICY CONSIDERATIONS WHICH REQUIRE THE
SINGAPORE COURTS NOT TO APPLY THE DOCTRINE OF
TRANSNATIONAL ISSUE ESTOPPEL TO ANY QUESTION RELATING TO
STATE IMMUNITY?.........................................................................................59
ARE THERE ANY OTHER SPECIAL CIRCUMSTANCES WHICH RENDER
TRANSNATIONAL ISSUE ESTOPPEL INAPPLICABLE? ........................................61
CONCLUSION...............................................................................................61
ii
Version No 1: 25 Jul 2025 (17:12 hrs)
This judgment is subject to final editorial corrections approved by the
court and/or redaction pursuant to the publisher’s duty in compliance
with the law, for publication in LawNet and/or the Singapore Law
Reports.
Hulley Enterprises Ltd and others
v
The Russian Federation
[2025] SGHC(I) 19
Singapore International Commercial Court — Originating Application No 5 of
2025 (High Court (General Division) Summons No 286 of 2025)
Andre Maniam J, James Allsop IJ and Anthony Meagher IJ
25 April 2025
25 July 2025 Judgment reserved.
Anthony Meagher IJ (delivering the joint judgment of Andre Maniam J
and himself):
Introduction
1 On 20 May 2024, a judge in the General Division of the High Court
made an ex parte order pursuant to s 29 of the International Arbitration Act 1994
(2020 Rev Ed) (the “IAA”) and O 48 r 6(2) of the Rules of Court 2021 (the
“Leave Order”), granting leave to each of the claimants – Hulley Enterprises
Ltd (“Hulley”), Yukos Universal Ltd (“Yukos Universal”), and Veteran
Petroleum Ltd (“Veteran”) (together, the “Claimants”) – to enforce a final
arbitral award in its favour and against the defendant (the “Russian
Federation”). The three final awards (the “Final Awards”) had been delivered
on 18 July 2014, in arbitrat
……
基本案情
申请人寻求执行外国仲裁裁决,被告俄罗斯联邦以国家豁免为由抗辩。争议焦点在……
案件文书
下载原始文书需登录会员账号。
