CJD v CJE and another
新加坡高等法院 · [2021] SGHC 61摘要
快速理解这份材料
编辑摘要
新加坡高等法院审理关于依据LCIA规则强制追加第三方当事人的管辖权异议案件。
文书原文
IN THE GENERAL DIVISION OF
THE HIGH COURT OF THE REPUBLIC OF SINGAPORE
[2021] SGHC 61
Originating Summons No 1446 of 2019
Between
CJD
… Plaintiff
And
(1) CJE
(2) CJF
… Defendants
GROUNDS OF DECISION
[Arbitration] — [Arbitral tribunal] — [Joinder of third parties] —
[Jurisdiction]
Version No 2: 24 Mar 2021 (12:14 hrs)
TABLE OF CONTENTS
INTRODUCTION............................................................................................1
FACTS...............................................................................................................3
THE ARBITRATION PROCEEDINGS AND THE TRIBUNAL’S DECISION..................6
DECISION ........................................................................................................8
A PRELIMINARY POINT ON THE COURT’S POWERS............................................8
A plea had been raised that the Tribunal lacked jurisdiction ..................11
The Decision was a negative determination on jurisdiction ....................12
THERE WAS NO CONSENT IN WRITING BY THE 2ND DEFENDANT TO
BEING JOINED ................................................................................................14
THE DOCTRINE OF DOUBLE SEPARABILITY ....................................................20
CONCLUSION...............................................................................................24
i
Version No 2: 24 Mar 2021 (12:14 hrs)
This judgment is subject to final editorial corrections approved by the
court and/or redaction pursuant to the publisher’s duty in compliance
with the law, for publication in LawNet and/or the Singapore Law
Reports.
CJD v
CJE and another
[2021] SGHC 61
General Division of the High Court — Originating Summons No 1446 of 2019
S Mohan JC
30 July, 4 September 2020
19 March 2021
S Mohan JC:
Introduction
1 The principle of party autonomy lies at the very heart of arbitration and
permeates practically all aspects of it. Party autonomy allows parties a wide
latitude to agree on almost all aspects of how a dispute is to be arbitrated. In the
context of a multi-party contract, that autonomy may include the ability to agree
on who may be party to an arbitration reference in the event a dispute arises.
2 Underpinning the principle of party autonomy is the fundamental
principle of consent or agreement of the parties. Thus, in an area of dispute
resolution where consent plays such a central role, the notion of a “forced
joinder” of a party would appear somewhat out of place and, some might say,
anathema to the very definition of consent.
Version No 2: 24 Mar 2021 (12:14 hrs)
CJD v CJE [2021] SGHC 61
3 Certain institutional arbitration rules do, however, empower an arbitral
tribunal to order a forced joinder of third parties in certain circumstances.
Among these are the London Court of International Arbitration Rules 2014
(“LCIA Rules 2014”). I refer in particular to Article 22.1(viii) of the LCIA
Rules 2014.
4 In this regard, a “forced joinder” refers to a third party consenting to be
joined as a party to extant arbitration proceedings on the application of one of
the arbitrants despite objections to the joinder raised by the other arbitrant(s).
Thus, notwithstanding the impression given by the phrase, a “forced joinder”
does not in fact refer to forcing a third party to join an arbitration against its
wishes. Nevertheless, the application of a forced joinder has been viewed as a
significant derogation from the principle of party autonomy and consent (see,
for example, the Court of Appeal decision in PT First Media TBK (formerly
known as PT Broadband Multimedia TBK v Astro Nusantara International BV
and others and another appeal [2014] 1 SLR 372 (“PT First Media”) at [188]).
5 The application before me in Originating Summons No 1446 of 2019
(“OS 1446”) raised interesting issues revolving around the proper interpretation
and ambit of Article 22.1(viii) of the LCIA Rules 2014. As there is sparse
authority on forced joinders in general and Article 22.1(viii) of the LCIA Rules
2014 in particular, this case presents a good opportunity to consider the issues
in greater detail. I thus provide the full grounds for my decision. I start by
summarising the material facts.
2
Version No 2: 24 Mar 2021 (12:14 hrs)
CJD v CJE [2021] SGHC 61
Facts
6 The plaintiff is CJD (“plaintiff”). It is a limited liability company
incorporated and existing under the laws of Narnia. The plaintiff is the
respondent in the underlying arbitration (“Arbitration”).
7 The first defendant is CJE (“1st defendant”), an offshore company also
incorporated in Narnia. It is the claimant in the Arbitration. The second
defendant is CJF (“2nd defendant”), a limited liability company incorporated in
Telmar. The 2nd defendant owns 100% of the issued shares in the 1st defendant.1
It is not a party to the Arbitration.
8 On 24 April 2014, the plaintiff entered into a joint venture agreement
(“Joint Venture Agreement”) with the 1st defendant, 2nd defendant and three
other parties for the purpose of developing a mixed-use residential/commercial
tower, hotel and/or service apartments
……
基本案情
原告CJD与被告CJE、CJF发生争议,涉及仲裁程序中依据LCI……
裁判要旨
裁判要旨
法院审查了仲裁庭在缺乏书面同意的情况下强制追加……
案件文书
下载原始文书需登录会员账号。
