Moveon Technologies Pte Ltd v Crystal-Moveon Technologies Pte Ltd
新加坡高等法院 · [2024] SGHCR 2摘要
快速理解这份材料
编辑摘要
新加坡高等法院就Moveon诉Crystal-Moveon案作出判决,涉及依据《仲裁法》中止诉讼程序的裁量权。
文书原文
IN THE GENERAL DIVISION OF
THE HIGH COURT OF THE REPUBLIC OF SINGAPORE
[2024] SGHCR 2
Originating Claim No 421 of 2023 (Summons No 2865 of 2023)
Between
Moveon Technologies Pte Ltd
… Claimant
And
Crystal-Moveon Technologies
Pte Ltd
… Defendant
GROUNDS OF DECISION
[Arbitration — Stay of court proceedings — Court’s discretion under
Arbitration Act]
Version No 2: 19 Jan 2024 (08:50 hrs)
TABLE OF CONTENTS
INTRODUCTION............................................................................................1
BACKGROUND ..............................................................................................2
THE APPLICABLE PRINCIPLES ...............................................................4
THE SUBMISSIONS .......................................................................................7
THE ISSUES.....................................................................................................9
WHETHER ONLY THE AH EQUIPMENT CLAIMS OR THE
ENTIRETY OF MTPL’S CLAIM FOR THE EQUIPMENT
COSTS FALL WITHIN THE SCOPE OF THE ARBITRATION
AGREEMENT IN THE ETA? .....................................................................10
WHETHER CMT HAD SHOWN THE EXISTENCE OF A
“DISPUTE” COMING WITHIN THE SCOPE OF THE
ARBITRATION AGREEMENT IN THE ETA..........................................13
WHAT DOES A DEFENDANT/STAY APPLICANT HAVE TO SHOW IN ORDER
TO DEMONSTRATE THE EXISTENCE OF A “DISPUTE” THAT IS
REFERABLE TO ARBITRATION?.......................................................................13
It is sufficient for the defendant/stay applicant to assert that he
disputes or denies the claim .....................................................................14
Whether the defendant’s defence is valid or sustainable goes
towards the issue of whether there is “sufficient reason” for a
stay to be refused......................................................................................20
The other authorities cited by MTPL .......................................................24
WHETHER CMT HAD DEMONSTRATED THE EXISTENCE OF A “DISPUTE”
IN THIS CASE..................................................................................................27
WHETHER MTPL HAD SHOWN “SUFFICIENT REASON”
FOR A STAY OF PROCEEDINGS TO BE REFUSED ............................28
i
Version No 2: 19 Jan 2024 (08:50 hrs)
FACTORS GERMANE TO SHOWING “SUFFICIENT REASON” FOR THE
REFUSAL OF A STAY UNDER S 6 OF THE AA ...................................................28
WHETHER THERE IS “SUFFICIENT REASON” IN THIS CASE ..............................36
WHETHER THE AH EQUIPMENT CLAIMS ARE “UNDISPUTED” OR
“INDISPUTABLE” ...........................................................................................40
CONCLUSION...............................................................................................43
ii
Version No 2: 19 Jan 2024 (08:50 hrs)
This judgment is subject to final editorial corrections approved by the
court and/or redaction pursuant to the publisher’s duty in compliance
with the law, for publication in LawNet and/or the Singapore Law
Reports.
Moveon Technologies Pte Ltd
v
Crystal-Moveon Technologies Pte Ltd
[2024] SGHCR 2
General Division of the High Court — Originating Claim No 421 of 2023
(Summons No 2865 of 2023)
AR Perry Peh
9 November 2023, 4 January 2024
16 January 2024
AR Perry Peh:
Introduction
1 HC/SUM 2865/2023 (“SUM 2865”) was an application by the
defendant in HC/OC 421/2023 (“OC 421”) to stay a part of the claimant’s
claims in OC 421 pursuant to s 6 of the Arbitration Act 2001 (2020 Rev Ed)
(“the AA”), on the basis that the parties have agreed to refer these claims to
arbitration. The parties were not in disagreement that this part of the claimant’s
claims indeed fall within the scope of an arbitration agreement between them.
However, they were divided on whether it was sufficient for the defendant, in
seeking a stay under s 6 of the AA, to establish the existence of a “dispute”
referable to arbitration by merely asserting that it disputes or denies those
claims, or whether the defendant was required to back up its assertion of a
dispute by credible evidence. Having considered the authorities, I came down
Version No 2: 19 Jan 2024 (08:50 hrs)
Moveon Technologies Pte Ltd v Crystal-Moveon [2024] SGHCR 2
Technologies Pte Ltd
in favour of the former, though I found that there was “sufficient reason” in this
case for the claims to not be referred to arbitration, and I therefore dismissed
SUM 2865. These are my grounds of decision.
Background
2 The defendant, Crystal-Moveon Technologies Pte Ltd (“CMT”) was
incorporated for a joint venture between one Zhejiang Crystal Optech Co Ltd
(“COC”), a PRC-incorporated company and the claimant, Moveon
Technologies Pte Ltd (“MTPL”), a Singapore-incorporated company. CMT was
also a Singapore-incorporated company. The joint venture between COC and
MTPL was entered into sometime in October 2021. According to CMT, the
parties had decided to terminate the joint venture sometime in May 2022,1
though I note it was not stated in MTPL’s Statement of Claim (“t
……
基本案情
原告Moveon起诉被告Crystal-Moveon,被告申请中止诉讼以……
裁判要旨
裁判要旨
法院分析了被告需证明存在“争议”的标准,以及拒绝中止诉讼所需……
案件文书
下载原始文书需登录会员账号。
