FIC Properties Sdn Bhd v PT Rajawali Capital International and another
Singapore International Commercial Court · [2024] SGHC(I) 33摘要
快速理解这份材料
编辑摘要
FIC Properties与Rajawali集团就仲裁裁决的撤销申请(基于欺诈、违法及程序不公)及执行问题的诉讼。
文书原文
IN THE SINGAPORE INTERNATIONAL COMMERCIAL COURT
OF THE REPUBLIC OF SINGAPORE
[2024] SGHC(I) 33
Originating Application No 14 of 2024 (Summons No 38 of 2024)
Between
FIC Properties Sdn Bhd
… Claimant
And
(1) PT Rajawali Capital
International
(2) PT Rajawali Corpora
… Defendants
Originating Application No 21 of 2024
Between
(1) PT Rajawali Capital
International
(2) PT Rajawali Corpora
… Claimants
And
FIC Properties Sdn Bhd
… Defendant
JUDGMENT
Version No 2: 17 Dec 2024 (18:11 hrs)
[Arbitration — Award — Recourse against award — Setting aside — Fraud]
[Arbitration — Award — Recourse against award — Setting aside —
Illegality]
[Arbitration — Award — Recourse against award — Setting aside — Natural
justice]
[Arbitration — Award — Enforcement]
Version No 2: 17 Dec 2024 (18:11 hrs)
TABLE OF CONTENTS
INTRODUCTION............................................................................................ 1
BACKGROUND .............................................................................................. 2
THE RELEVANT CONTRACTUAL ARRANGEMENTS ............................................ 2
THE GOVCO PLEDGE ...................................................................................... 6
THE FIRST ARBITRATION ................................................................................ 6
THE SECOND ARBITRATION ............................................................................ 7
THE PROCEDURAL HISTORY .................................................................. 9
THE RAJAWALIS’ GROUNDS FOR SETTING-ASIDE ........................ 10
GROUND 1: THE FRAUD GROUND ........................................................ 11
THE RAJAWALIS’ SUBMISSIONS .................................................................... 11
THE NON-DISCLOSURE ARGUMENT .............................................................. 13
THE MISREPRESENTATION ARGUMENT ......................................................... 19
GROUND 2: THE ILLEGALITY GROUND ............................................. 26
GROUND 3: THE NATURAL JUSTICE GROUND ................................. 28
THE SECOND TRIBUNAL’S ALLEGED FAILURE TO ACKNOWLEDGE
PARTIES’ COMMON GROUND IN THE FIRST ARBITRATION .............................. 28
THE SECOND TRIBUNAL’S ALLEGED FAILURE TO CONSIDER AN
ARGUMENT RAISED BY THE RAJAWALIS IN THE SECOND ARBITRATION ........ 30
CONCLUSION .............................................................................................. 31
i
Version No 2: 17 Dec 2024 (18:11 hrs)
This judgment is subject to final editorial corrections approved by the
court and/or redaction pursuant to the publisher’s duty in compliance
with the law, for publication in LawNet and/or the Singapore Law
Reports.
FIC Properties Sdn Bhd
v
PT Rajawali Capital International and another and another
matter
[2024] SGHC(I) 33
Singapore International Commercial Court — Originating Application No 14
of 2024 (Summons No 38 of 2024) and Originating Application No 21 of
2024
Philip Jeyaretnam J, Roger Giles IJ and Yuko Miyazaki IJ
4 November 2024, 18 November 2024
16 December 2024 Judgment reserved.
Philip Jeyaretnam J (delivering the judgment of the court):
Introduction
1 SIC/OA 14/2024 (“OA 14”) was an application by FIC Properties Sdn
Bhd (“FIC”) for permission to enforce Singapore International Arbitration
Centre Award No. 076 of 2024 (the “Second Award”)1 against PT Rajawali
Capital International and PT Rajawali Corpora (respectively, “Rajawali
Capital” and “Rajawali Corpora”; collectively, the “Rajawalis”) in Singapore.
An order granting FIC permission to do so (the “Enforcement Order”) was made
by the learned Deputy Registrar on 11 July 2024. SIC/OA 21/2024 (“OA 21”)
1 Rizki Indra Kusuma’s witness statement dated 23 August 2024 filed in SIC/OA
14/2024 (“RIK-1”) at pp 280–358 (the “Second Award”).
Version No 2: 17 Dec 2024 (18:11 hrs)
FIC Properties Sdn Bhd v PT Rajawali Capital International [2024] SGHC 33
and SIC/SUM 38/2024 (“SUM 38”) are respectively the Rajawalis’
cross-applications to set aside the Second Award and the Enforcement Order.
2 The Rajawalis raised three grounds in support of their applications,
namely fraud, illegality and breach of natural justice. Having considered the
evidence and parties’ submissions, we hold that none of the Rajawalis’ grounds
for setting-aside the Second Award or the Enforcement Order have been made
out. OA 21 and SUM 38 are therefore dismissed. These are our reasons.
Background
3 Rajawali Capital is an Indonesian company and a subsidiary of Rajawali
Corpora. Both companies are part of the wider Indonesian conglomerate
commonly referred to as the “Rajawali Group”.2
4 FIC, on the other hand, is a Malaysian company that is wholly owned
by the Federal Land Development Authority of Malaysia (“FELDA”). FIC is a
corporate vehicle through which FELDA pursues its commercial dealings.3
The relevant contractual arrangements
5 The parties’ underlying dispute arose out of a contract dated 23
December 2016 (the “SPA”)4 by which Rajawali Capital agreed to sell, and FIC
agreed to purchase, shares (the “EHP Shares”
……
基本案情
涉及两起仲裁案件,被告方以欺诈、违法及违反自然……
裁判要旨
裁判要旨
法院经审查证据与陈述后认为,申请人提出的撤销仲裁裁决及执行令……
案件文书
下载原始文书需登录会员账号。
