Palm Grove Beach Hotels Pvt. Ltd. v Hilton Worldwide Manage Limited and another
新加坡高等法院 · [2024] SGHC 125摘要
快速理解这份材料
编辑摘要
新加坡高等法院审理Palm Grove申请撤销Hilton相关仲裁裁决一案,重点审查仲裁庭对反诉中准备问题和表现问题的处理是否合规。
文书原文
IN THE GENERAL DIVISION OF
THE HIGH COURT OF THE REPUBLIC OF SINGAPORE
[2024] SGHC 125
Originating Application No 1203 of 2023
Between
Palm Grove Beach Hotels Pvt.
Ltd.
… Claimant
And
(1) Hilton Worldwide Manage
Limited
(2) Hilton Hotels Management
India Private Limited
… Defendants
JUDGMENT
[Arbitration — Award — Recourse against award — Setting aside]
Version No 1: 10 May 2024 (10:21 hrs)
TABLE OF CONTENTS
THE FACTS .....................................................................................................2
THE AGREEMENTS ...........................................................................................3
THE RELEVANT CONTRACTUAL PROVISIONS....................................................5
Hilton’s duties in relation to the management and operation of the
Hotel ...........................................................................................................5
The preparation and approval of the Hotel’s annual budgets ...................6
The provision of working capital by Palm Grove ......................................8
The Performance Tests.............................................................................10
EVENTS SUBSEQUENT TO THE OPENING OF THE HOTEL..................................11
THE ARBITRAL PROCEEDINGS.............................................................12
ARB 122 AND THE 1ST PARTIAL AWARD......................................................13
ARB 234 AND THE 2ND PARTIAL AWARD.....................................................14
ARB 044, ARB 343, AND THE 3RD PARTIAL AWARD ...................................15
PALM GROVE’S SETTING-ASIDE APPLICATION .............................16
ISSUE (A): PALM GROVE’S COUNTERCLAIM....................................17
THE PREPARATION ISSUE ..............................................................................18
The applicable principles .........................................................................19
Palm Grove’s Response to the Notice of Arbitration...............................23
The parties’ list of issues ..........................................................................26
Palm Grove’s pleadings ...........................................................................28
(1) Palm Grove’s Statement of Defence ...........................................29
(2) Palm Grove’s Counterclaim........................................................29
(3) Palm Grove’s Rejoinder..............................................................35
i
Version No 1: 10 May 2024 (10:21 hrs)
The pre-hearing submissions and post-hearing briefs .............................39
The evidence led in the Second Tranche Arbitration ...............................44
The Preparation Issue was not adequately pleaded.................................47
THE UNDERPERFORMANCE ISSUE .................................................................48
The Tribunal did not err in dismissing Palm Grove’s counterclaim
on evidential grounds ...............................................................................51
(1) There was no “common and agreed position” on how the
Underperformance Issue should have been determined..............51
(2) The Tribunal addressed its mind to the parties’ evidence
and arguments before concluding that there was
insufficient evidence ...................................................................56
(3) The Tribunal was not obliged to call for expert evidence...........58
The Tribunal did not err in concluding that the Settlement
Agreement was irrelevant.........................................................................60
Conclusion................................................................................................61
ISSUE (B): THE AFFILIATE FEES CLAIM.............................................61
ISSUE (C): THE WORKING CAPITAL CLAIM .....................................65
THE TRIBUNAL CONSIDERED THE FORCE MAJEURE DEFENCE.......................65
THE TRIBUNAL CONSIDERED THE WRONGFUL REQUEST DEFENCE ...............68
ISSUE (D): THE SUSPENSION CLAIM ....................................................71
ISSUE (E): THE APPOINTMENT OF PROGNOSIS ...............................75
THE TRIBUNAL DID NOT DEPART FROM THE CHAIN OF REASONING IT
ADOPTED IN THE 1ST PARTIAL AWARD .........................................................76
THE TRIBUNAL DID NOT EXCEED THE SCOPE OF ITS JURISDICTION IN
REACHING ITS DECISION TO APPOINT PROGNOSIS ..........................................80
CONCLUSION...............................................................................................83
ii
Version No 1: 10 May 2024 (10:21 hrs)
This judgment is subject to final editorial corrections approved by the
court and/or redaction pursuant to the publisher’s duty in compliance
with the law, for publication in LawNet and/or the Singapore Law
Reports.
Palm Grove Beach Hotels Pvt Ltd
v
Hilton Worldwide Manage Ltd and another
[2024] SGHC 125
General Division of the High Court — Originating Application No 1203 of
2023
S Mohan J
15 March 2024
10 May 2024 Judgment reserved
……
基本案情
Palm Grove与Hilton就酒店管理及运营发生争议,进入仲裁程序(ARB 122, 234, 044等)。Palm Grove……
裁判要旨
裁判要旨
法院认为仲裁庭在认定业绩不足问题、结算协议相关性、不可抗力抗辩……
案件文书
下载原始文书需登录会员账号。
