COD v COE
新加坡高等法院 · [2022] SGHC 126摘要
快速理解这份材料
编辑摘要
申请人以仲裁员违反自然正义及既定仲裁程序为由,请求撤销仲裁裁决。
文书原文
IN THE GENERAL DIVISION OF
THE HIGH COURT OF THE REPUBLIC OF SINGAPORE
[2022] SGHC 126
Originating Summons No 925 of 2021
Between
COD
… Applicant
And
COE
… Respondent
JUDGMENT
[Arbitration — Award — Recourse against award — Setting aside — Natural
justice]
Version No 2: 25 May 2022 (12:34 hrs)
TABLE OF CONTENTS
INTRODUCTION............................................................................................1
FACTS...............................................................................................................2
THE PARTIES ...................................................................................................2
BACKGROUND TO THE DISPUTE .......................................................................2
PROCEDURAL HISTORY..................................................................................10
THE PARTIES’ CASES................................................................................12
COD’S SUBMISSIONS ....................................................................................12
COE’S SUBMISSIONS .....................................................................................15
ISSUES TO BE DETERMINED ..................................................................16
ISSUE 1: DID THE ARBITRATOR PROCEED CONTRARY TO
THE ARBITRAL PROCEDURE AGREED BY THE PARTIES,
THAT IS TO HAVE ONLY ONE TRANCHE OF HEARING
WITHOUT BIFURCATION INTO LIABILITY AND
QUANTUM PHASES? ..................................................................................17
ISSUE 2: WAS COE’S CLAIM FOR DAMAGES IN LIEU OF
SPECIFIC PERFORMANCE BASED ON THE FORMULA OF
BALANCE CONTRACT PRICE LESS SCRAP VALUE
INTRODUCED ONLY AFTER THE INTERIM AWARD? ....................20
ISSUE 3: DID THE ARBITRATOR, IN BREACH OF NATURAL
JUSTICE, ALLOW COE TO ADVANCE THIS CLAIM
WITHOUT GIVING COD A FAIR AND REASONABLE
OPPORTUNITY TO RESPOND? ...............................................................25
ISSUE 4: DID THE ARBITRATOR, IN BREACH OF NATURAL
JUSTICE, FAIL TO CONSIDER COD’S ARGUMENTS
DISPUTING COE’S CONTENTION THAT THERE WAS NO
AVAILABLE MARKET FOR THE CRANES?.........................................25
i
Version No 2: 25 May 2022 (12:34 hrs)
CONCLUSION...............................................................................................27
ii
Version No 2: 25 May 2022 (12:34 hrs)
This judgment is subject to final editorial corrections approved by the
court and/or redaction pursuant to the publisher’s duty in compliance
with the law, for publication in LawNet and/or the Singapore Law
Reports.
COD
v
COE
[2022] SGHC 126
General Division of the High Court — Originating Summons No 925 of 2021
Philip Jeyaretnam J
13–14 April 2022
25 May 2022 Judgment reserved.
Philip Jeyaretnam J:
Introduction
1 Arbitration, like any process for dispute resolution, is dynamic. Parties
make choices of what to emphasise and what to contest. The arbitrator must
make sense of what may be complex submissions that interlock and interact. It
is generally not wrong for an arbitrator to seek further submissions from parties
when this might help his task to adjudicate fairly and justly. Indeed, doing so
might well be considered part of doing justice in the round, rather than, as
claimed by the applicant in these proceedings, a breach of agreed procedure and
of natural justice.
Version No 2: 25 May 2022 (12:34 hrs)
COD v COE [2022] SGHC 126
Facts
The parties
2 This is an application under s 48 of the Arbitration Act
(Cap 10, 2002 Rev Ed) (the “AA”) to set aside a final award dated 21 June 2021.
The applicant, COD, is a company incorporated in Singapore. It is a shipbuilder.
The respondent, COE, is also a company incorporated in Singapore. It makes
marine and offshore equipment.1
Background to the dispute
3 COE contracted to make and deliver to COD two identical fibre rope
cranes (the “Cranes”).2 There was one contract for each crane on the same terms
(“the contracts”). Both contained an identical arbitration clause.3
4 While COD considered fibre rope cranes to be better than traditional
steel wire rope cranes because of higher buoyancy and lighter weight, such
cranes were also quite new to the market.4 The Cranes were intended to be
mounted on COD’s vessels for use in offshore operations.5
5 After the contracted delivery dates for the Cranes had passed, COD
terminated each of the contracts on the same ground, namely non-compliance
1 1st Affidavit of COD’s representative dated 10 September 2021 (“1COD1–17COD1”)
vol 1 at paras 8–9.
2 1COD1 at paras 10–11.
3 1COD1 at para 33.
4 1COD1 at para 11, Respondent’s written submissions dated 6 April 2022 (“COE WS”)
at para 18.
5 1COD1 at para 12.
2
Version No 2: 25 May 2022 (12:34 hrs)
COD v COE [2022] SGHC 126
with contractual specifications and requirements.6 COD did not take delivery.7
COE commenced two arbitrations alleging breach of contract on the basis of
wrongful refusal to take delivery of the Cranes. COE sought specific
performance and payment of the balance contract price of the Cranes, with
damages in the alternative. Pending the outcome of the proceedi
……
基本案情
COD与COE发生争议并提交仲裁。COD主张仲裁员违反了双方约定的单一阶段审理程序,且在未给予其公……
裁判要旨
裁判要旨
仲裁员为公正裁判而寻求当事人进一步陈述通常并无不当,此……
案件文书
下载原始文书需登录会员账号。
