Hunan Xiangzhong Mining Group Ltd v Oilive Pte Ltd
新加坡高等法院 · [2022] SGHC 43摘要
快速理解这份材料
编辑摘要
湘中矿业申请宣告SIAC仲裁案独任仲裁员无管辖权,涉及管辖权异议时限及仲裁员任命程序争议。
文书原文
IN THE GENERAL DIVISION OF
THE HIGH COURT OF THE REPUBLIC OF SINGAPORE
[2022] SGHC 43
Originating Summons No 920 of 2021
Between
Hunan Xiangzhong Mining
Group Ltd
… Plaintiff
And
Oilive Pte Ltd
… Defendant
JUDGMENT
[Arbitration — Arbitral tribunal — Jurisdiction]
[Arbitration — Arbitral tribunal — Appointment of arbitrator]
[Arbitration — Arbitral tribunal — Singapore International Arbitration Centre
— Whether sole arbitrator is to be appointed by Chairman or President]
Version No 1: 28 Feb 2022 (10:24 hrs)
TABLE OF CONTENTS
INTRODUCTION............................................................................................1
FACTUAL BACKGROUND ..........................................................................3
THE JURISDICTIONAL CHALLENGE AND THE
JURISDICTION DECISION..........................................................................8
THE PARTIES’ CASES................................................................................16
ISSUES ............................................................................................................21
FIRST ISSUE: WAS THE PLAINTIFF’S JURISDICTIONAL
CHALLENGE BEFORE THE ARBITRATOR MADE OUT OF
TIME AND IF SO, WHETHER THE COURT IS PRECLUDED
FROM HEARING THE CHALLENGE DE NOVO UNDER S
10(3) IAA.........................................................................................................21
THE PARTIES’ ARGUMENTS............................................................................21
ANALYSIS AND DECISION ..............................................................................22
SECOND ISSUE: WHETHER THE ARBITRATOR HAS
JURISDICTION OVER THE ARBITRATION .........................................35
THE PARTIES’ ARGUMENTS............................................................................35
ANALYSIS AND DECISION ..............................................................................35
CONCLUSION...............................................................................................49
ii
Version No 1: 28 Feb 2022 (10:24 hrs)
This judgment is subject to final editorial corrections approved by the
court and/or redaction pursuant to the publisher’s duty in compliance
with the law, for publication in LawNet and/or the Singapore Law
Reports.
Hunan Xiangzhong Mining Group Ltd v
Oilive Pte Ltd
[2022] SGHC 43
General Division of the High Court — Originating Summons No 920 of 2021
S Mohan J
2 December 2021
28 February 2022 Judgment reserved.
S Mohan J:
Introduction
1 In HC/OS 920/2021 (“OS 920”), the plaintiff, Hunan Xiangzhong
Mining Group Limited applies, pursuant to s 10(3)(a) of the International
Arbitration Act (Cap 143A, 2002 Rev Ed) (“IAA”), for a declaration that the
sole arbitrator, Mr Timothy Cooke (“Arbitrator”), does not have jurisdiction
over the arbitration proceedings in Singapore International Arbitration Centre
(“SIAC”) Arbitration No 934 of 2020 (“Arbitration”). In a Ruling on
Jurisdiction dated 12 August 2021 (“Jurisdiction Decision”), the Arbitrator
ruled that he has jurisdiction over the Arbitration.1
2 It is well established that an application made under s 10(3) of the IAA
is to be reviewed by the court de novo. In considering the matter afresh, the
1 Zhao Meiqing’s affidavit dated 6 September 2021 (“Zhao’s affidavit”) at pp 17 to 36.
Version No 1: 28 Feb 2022 (10:24 hrs)
Hunan Xiangzhong Mining Group Ltd v Oilive Pte Ltd [2022] SGHC 43
court will consider the arbitral tribunal’s views on its jurisdiction, as what the
tribunal has said might well be persuasive. However, beyond this, the court is
not bound to accept or take into account the arbitral tribunal’s findings on the
matter (Sanum Investments Ltd v Government of the Lao People’s Democratic
Republic [2016] 5 SLR 536 at [41]).
3 The central controversy in OS 920 pertains to the validity of the
Arbitrator’s appointment. In essence, the plaintiff contends that the appointment
of the Arbitrator was not in accordance with the parties’ agreement in the
arbitration agreement contained in the underlying contract between the parties
(see [7] below).2 The relevant part of the arbitration agreement prescribed that
“THE TRIBUNAL SHALL CONSIST OF A SINGLE ARBITRATOR
AGREED UPON BY BOTH PARTIES, OR IF NOT SO AGREED, BY THE
CHAIRMAN FOR THE TIME BEING OF SIAC” [emphasis added in italics
and bold italics]. Since the Arbitrator in this case was appointed by the President
of the Court of Arbitration of the SIAC (“President”) and not the Chairman of
the SIAC (“Chairman”), the plaintiff’s position is that the Arbitrator’s
appointment is invalid.3 In response, the defendant submits that the appointment
procedures were correctly observed and the Arbitrator was properly appointed
under the SIAC Rules (6th edition, 1 August 2016) (“SIAC Rules 2016”).4 In
any case, the plaintiff’s application should fail because it was made to the
Arbitrator out of time.5
2 Plaintiff’s Written Submissions dated 25 November 2021 (“PWS”) at para 20.
3 PWS at paras 6 and 8.
4 Defendant’s Written Submissions dated 25 November 2021 (“DWS”) at paras 52 to
53.
5 DWS at par
……
基本案情
原告湘中矿业与被告Oilive在SIAC进行仲裁(编号934/2020)。原告对仲裁庭管辖权……
案件文书
下载原始文书需登录会员账号。
