Ng Tze Chew Diana v Aikco Construction Pte Ltd
新加坡高等法院 · [2019] SGHC 258摘要
快速理解这份材料
编辑摘要
申请人以仲裁员违反自然正义为由,请求撤销涉及建筑工程延误及财产价值损失的仲裁裁决。
文书原文
IN THE HIGH COURT OF THE REPUBLIC OF SINGAPORE
[2019] SGHC 258
Originating Summons No 1010 of 2018
Between
Ng Tze Chew Diana
… Applicant
And
Aikco Construction Pte Ltd
… Respondent
Originating Summons No 1108 of 2018
(Summons No 5038 of 2018)
Between
Aikco Construction Pte Ltd
… Plaintiff
And
Ng Tze Chew Diana
… Defendant
JUDGMENT
[Arbitration] — [Award] — [Breach of natural justice]
Version No 1: 27 Oct 2020 (22:41 hrs)
TABLE OF CONTENTS
INTRODUCTION............................................................................................1
FACTS...............................................................................................................2
THE PARTIES....................................................................................................2
BACKGROUND TO THE DISPUTE .......................................................................2
THE ARBITRATION PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE RESPONDENT .........................4
THE APPLICATIONS FILED IN COURT ................................................................8
THE PARTIES’ CASES..................................................................................9
THE APPLICANT’S CASE ...................................................................................9
THE RESPONDENT’S CASE ..............................................................................11
ISSUES TO BE DETERMINED ..................................................................13
APPLICABLE LEGAL PRINCIPLES........................................................15
ADEQUATE NOTICE AND OPPORTUNITY TO BE HEARD....................................16
APPARENT BIAS .............................................................................................17
NEED FOR ACTUAL OR REAL PREJUDICE ........................................................18
DID THE ARBITRATOR FAIL TO DECIDE THE ISSUE OF
WHETHER THE APPLICANT IS ENTITLED TO GENERAL
DAMAGES FOR DELAY?...........................................................................19
DID THE ARBITRATOR FAIL TO CONSIDER THE
APPLICANT’S 8 JANUARY 2016 SUBMISSIONS ON THE
QUESTIONS OF THE VALIDITY OF THE DELAY
CERTIFICATES?..........................................................................................25
DID THE ARBITRATOR BREACH THE RULES OF NATURAL
JUSTICE IN THE MANNER IN WHICH HE DEALT WITH THE
i
Version No 1: 27 Oct 2020 (22:41 hrs)
APPLICANT’S CLAIM FOR LOSS IN VALUE OF THE
PROPERTY?..................................................................................................29
THE TEXT MESSAGE.......................................................................................30
ENTERING INTO THE FRAY DURING THE ORAL EVIDENCE OF MR GOH ...........31
THE ARBITRATOR’S ALLEGED RELIANCE ON HIS OWN KNOWLEDGE AND
EXPERIENCE ..................................................................................................33
RELIANCE ON A “WELL-KNOWN FACT”..........................................................34
DID THE ARBITRATOR BREACH NATURAL JUSTICE IN
THE MANNER IN WHICH HE DEALT WITH THE
APPLICANT’S CLAIM FOR DAMAGES FOR DEFECTIVE
WORKS? ........................................................................................................38
THE RECALLING OF THE ARCHITECT AS A WITNESS ON THE ISSUE OF
DEFECTIVE WORKS ........................................................................................38
THE ARBITRATOR’S TREATMENT OF THE APPLICANT’S
QUANTUM EXPERT’S EVIDENCE..........................................................44
PREFERENCE FOR MR WONG’S EVIDENCE .....................................................44
ARBITRATOR’S MISTAKE ...............................................................................47
CONCLUSION...............................................................................................48
ii
Version No 1: 27 Oct 2020 (22:41 hrs)
This judgment is subject to final editorial corrections approved by the
court and/or redaction pursuant to the publisher’s duty in compliance
with the law, for publication in LawNet and/or the Singapore Law
Reports.
Ng Tze Chew Diana
v
Aikco Construction Pte Ltd and another matter
[2019] SGHC 258
High Court — Originating Summons Nos 1010 of 2018 and 1108 of 2018
(Summons No 5038 of 2018)
Ang Cheng Hock J
3 December 2018, 28, 30 January 2019
5 November 2019 Judgment reserved.
Ang Cheng Hock J:
Introduction
1 This is an application to set aside an arbitral award on the basis that there
have been breaches of natural justice. There is also an accompanying
application to set aside the leave that has been granted to enforce the arbitral
award. The thrust of the application is that the arbitrator failed to determine
issues that were in dispute, that he ignored certain submissions and that he had
conducted himself in a manner which showed an apparent bias on his part. As
a result, it is alleged that the claimant in the arbitration was deprived of the
award of damages in several material respects.1 The task of this court is to
determine whether these claims for breach of natural justice have any basis.
1 Applicant’
……
基本案情
Ng Tze Chew Diana与Aikco Construction Pte Ltd因建……
案件文书
下载原始文书需登录会员账号。
